When should I start salary negotiation?

Negotiate after you receive a written offer, not during the interview process. During phone screens, give a range if pressed but defer specifics. Once you have the offer in writing, you have the most leverage because the company has already decided they want you.

How much above the offer should I counter?

A reasonable counter is 10 to 20 percent above the initial offer, depending on your leverage (competing offers, market data, unique qualifications). Counter with a specific number, not a range. If you ask for a range, the company will anchor to the bottom.

Can PrepPilot help during salary negotiation calls?

Yes. If your salary negotiation happens over a phone or video call, PrepPilot's Stealth Mode transcribes the recruiter's statements and generates real-time response suggestions on the invisible overlay. This is especially valuable for unexpected counter-arguments or pressure tactics.

What if the company says the offer is non-negotiable?

Most offers are negotiable even when companies say they are not. If base salary is truly fixed (common at some large companies with rigid pay bands), negotiate other components: signing bonus, equity, start date, remote flexibility, PTO, title, or performance review timing. Always negotiate something.

Should I reveal my current salary?

No. In many jurisdictions it is illegal for employers to ask, and in all cases you are better off framing the discussion around market value and the value you bring. Say: 'I prefer to focus on the value I can bring to this role and the market rate for this position rather than anchoring to my current compensation.'

Salary Negotiation Scripts — AI-Generated Word-for-Word

Eight common salary negotiation scenarios with exact scripts you can use over email, phone, or video call. Updated March 2026.

Scenario 1: Initial Counter-Offer (Base Salary Too Low)

You received a written offer but the base salary is below your target. You want to counter without seeming ungrateful or aggressive.

Script

Thank you so much for the offer. I am genuinely excited about this role and the team. After reviewing the compensation package, I would like to discuss the base salary. Based on my research into market rates for this role and level, and considering my [X years of experience / specific relevant qualification], I was targeting a base salary closer to [specific number]. I believe this reflects the value I would bring, particularly in [specific area you will contribute]. Is there flexibility to adjust the base?

Key principle: Always counter with a specific number, not a range. Express enthusiasm first. Justify with market data and your specific value, not personal financial needs.

Scenario 2: Negotiating Equity or Stock Options

The base salary is acceptable but the equity component is lower than expected, or you want more equity as part of the total package.

Script

I appreciate the offer and I am excited about the equity component. I see this as a long-term opportunity and I want my compensation to reflect that commitment. Given the current base, I would like to discuss increasing the equity grant to [specific number of shares or dollar value]. I am particularly motivated by the company's growth trajectory and I want to be meaningfully invested in that upside. Would you be able to increase the equity portion?

Scenario 3: Requesting a Signing Bonus

The company cannot move on base salary but you want additional compensation to bridge the gap or offset what you are leaving behind.

Script

I understand the base salary range is firm, and I respect that. I am leaving behind [unvested equity / a pending bonus / other compensation] at my current company by making this move. Would it be possible to include a signing bonus of [specific amount] to help bridge that gap? This would make the transition smoother and allow me to commit fully from day one without feeling like I left money on the table.

Scenario 4: Leveraging a Competing Offer

You have another offer and want to use it as leverage without appearing to be playing companies against each other.

Script

I want to be transparent with you. I have received another offer that is competitive, and I want to make the best decision. Your company is my top choice because of [specific reason], but the other offer is currently higher in [base / total compensation]. I am not trying to start a bidding war. I simply want to make sure the compensation reflects what the market is offering for my experience level. Is there room to adjust the offer to [specific number]?

Key principle: Only mention competing offers if they are real. Be specific about what is higher without revealing the company name. Make it clear the current company is your preference.

Scenario 5: Negotiating Remote Work or Flexibility

You want to negotiate work-from-home days, flexible hours, or fully remote work as part of the offer.

Script

I am excited about the role and the team. One thing that would make this an even stronger fit is flexibility in the work arrangement. I am most productive with [specific arrangement: three days remote, flexible start times, one week per month remote]. In my current role, this arrangement has allowed me to [specific productivity outcome]. Would the team be open to this kind of flexibility? I am happy to discuss what works best for the team's collaboration needs.

Scenario 6: Asking for a Higher Title

The offer comes with a title that is lower than your current title or your qualifications warrant.

Script

Thank you for the offer. I have a question about the title. Given my [X years of experience] and the scope of responsibilities described for this role, I was expecting a [Senior / Lead / Director] title. My current title is [current title], and moving to [offered title] would feel like a step back. I know titles vary across companies, so I want to understand the leveling structure. Is there flexibility to bring the role in at the [desired title] level?

Scenario 7: Negotiating Start Date

You need more time before starting than the company is requesting.

Script

I am fully committed to this role and I want to start strong. To do that, I need to [give proper notice / wrap up a project / take a brief break between roles]. Would it be possible to set the start date for [specific date]? I want to make sure I arrive focused and ready to contribute from day one rather than rushing through a transition. I am happy to begin any onboarding paperwork or reading in the meantime.

Scenario 8: Responding to a "Final Offer" Claim

The recruiter says this is their best and final offer. You want to try one more time.

Script

I appreciate you being upfront about that, and I respect the constraints. I am very close to accepting. The one thing that would make this a clear yes for me is [one specific ask: a 5K increase in base, an additional week of PTO, a 10K signing bonus]. I understand if it is truly not possible, but I wanted to ask directly. If we can get to that number, I am ready to sign today.

Key principle: When told an offer is final, make one small, specific ask tied to immediate acceptance. This gives the recruiter a concrete action and a clear outcome. Do not make multiple asks at this point.

Explore More

Try Stealth Mode Free

50 free credits. No credit card. Real-time coaching for salary calls.

Download PrepPilot